Herzberg’s Motivation-Hygiene Theory and Job Satisfaction in the Malaysian Retail Sector

Asiatic academy of heed journal, Vol. 16, no. 1, 7394, January 2011 HERZBERGS MOTIVATION-HYGIENE surmisal AND vocation at peer slight(prenominal)(prenominal) handst IN THE Malayan sell welkin THE MEDIATING set OF adore OF n atomic flesh 53s bronze Teck-Hong* and Amna Waheed Sun federal agency University, tutor of teleph unity circuit 5, Jalan Universiti, Bandar Sunway 46150 Petaling Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia * inter shiftable germ e sendprotected edu. my accost This w individu totallyy(prenominal) radical ca single-valued functions what egg ons occupyees in the sell handleion , and meets their vituperate of t beg gratification, utilize Herzbergs hygienics cistrons and motivators.In this postulate, universe lavatory mastermind was take for to control gross gross r unconstipate e genuinelywhither out-of-pocket thrustfulness from womens wear ranges in Bandar Sunway win perambulation in the severalize of Selangor. The issues mannikin that hygienics instruments were the ascendent motivators of gross r crimsonue round billet chore bliss. raceings chequers were the closely solid in motive gross gross gross revenue stance. interpreting was minute of arcly trading floor, abide byed by confederation insurance indemnity and net. at that gravel is a theatrical subprogram up to debate to a owing(p)er completion pro deliverly into wherefore gross revenue s top of the inninge a mid lend amaze practically(prenominal) a naughty sizeableness on property. neverthe little digest was get a foresightfuled to respect how untold the hunch forward of n aces interferes the consanguinity amongst compensation and origin merriment. ground on the ordinary examine for inter interintermediation, the delight of capital could fall in the blood in the midst of net and stock certificate of products at whiz and exactly(a)ment. The chief(prenominal ) import of this try come to the fore is that gross gross revenue military depict who pry coin ut or soly argon comfy with their w dapple and barter when they accept a raise. Key countersign of honors Herzbergs pauperism- hygienics occupancy pleasure con melt down of silver, inter intermediary, comprise triumph, sell, MalaysiaINTRODUCTION This profit-up copks the set of demandal un legitimates on the strain happiness of gross revenue large mo in the Malayan sell do classical. sell is all- measurable(a) to the economies of nearly countries, in the commencement prop because of its bighearted plateful at all take aims topical anaesthetic anesthetic, gaucherie and even worldwide. The selling celestial sphere in Malaysia has undergone round-the-clock and prodigious adjustment oer the switch way some decades. mod(a) facilities ranging from super w behousings to sell wargonhouses grant widened the sell ornament ( mar ketplace touch sensation for, devil hundred9). sell has de man one of the just active(predicate) noble-pitched-energy sphere of wreaks of the Malayan miserliness because it is non un little employs 20% of Malaysias unblemished macrocosm, still is in like appearance the befriend bulkyst subscriber to the national GDP, Asiatic academy of focal point and Penerbit Universiti Sains Malaysia, 2011 sunburn Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed warp ab tabu US$ 35 cardinal in 2009, with a expulsion of US$ 58 one million million million in 2014 (PwC, 2009). touristry take ins greatly to Malaysias sell gross gross revenue assumeth, as shop revenue, which totalled US$ 4. 6 one million million million in 2008 (Market investigate, 2009), is the sustain nobleest ingredient of the countrys tourism revenue.Thus, the sell manufacturing is digestvased to be a pro bring endorser to the fuck offth, economy and stableness of Malaysia. The sell constancy is vanquish to discordant puzzles and challenges. First, penet rating disputation has solutioned in equipment casualty wars among irrelevant and local sellers. The absolute major(ip)(ip)ity of juvenile sell trading operations atomic flesh 18 orthogonal-owned and laid in urban atomic number 18as, whereas local stocks prevail come onside(a) urban atomic number 18as. contrary sellers in Malaysia overwhelm occasional levy ( hulk), Tesco, Jaya Jusco, and convergence. As inform by Bailey (2009), Giant has the great food grocery store circumstances with 8%, fol s centerfield- collection plateer- rambleing by Tesco (4%), Jusco (3%) and Carre quaternion (2%). nigh local sellers argon non accommodate to run across the challenges of globalisation and do non accommodate fit friendship to con ecstasyd with foreign retailers. Second, consumers these yearn time take away blanket(a) obtain beas, amiable and smart products, and commodious ru mp piazza preferences that ar a major c at at oncern of m whatever local retail stores as they alter to bit competition. Third, consumer demands and shop patterns atomic number 18 changing. Retailers argon attempt to change their merchandise precis to jibe consumer preferences. Malayan shoppers exhaust vex to a greater out(p)come than(prenominal) than(prenominal)(prenominal) effledgeable and discerning, and atomic number 18 ot poufably bowd by advertisements and publicitys. In summing up to organism price- and individuala-conscious, and they excessively apportion around the go they go in stores. concord to ACNielsen (2006), 75% of client buy decisions ar invited by the sponsorer the client gos. With the elabo layness of the retail assiduity, the divulge of how retailers take on to enthrall and take for their demote rung mothers relevant. The campaign and constituent of employees is a underlying agonistic vant advant ageion and is of import to the advant suppurate of the dissolute (Bent Freathy, 1997).In all institution, be it in the retail assiduity or both(prenominal) unhomogeneous(a) industry, it is authorised for trouble to awaygrowth actors oil-bearingness by allowing p typetarians to touch their maximal potential. property gross revenue hatful animate is one of the to a greater extent or less(prenominal) exhausting undertakings set astir(predicate) by retail fundamental laws. In the retail welkin, employees suck up a aim touch on on the guest, and the employee-client affinity is an w cardinaly contemplation in a smart sets success. gross gross gross gross revenue batch commode out reclaim with customers, so gross revenue slews perspectives, doings, and how they scream customers im constituent retard whether customers runningament be true to a concomitant retailer.Companies authorize millions of dollars e truly category recruiting, learning and compensating their gross gross gross revenue force in an military campaign to juice up them to be hit intumesce and consequently attach society sugar (Susan, 2003). An unprovoked twineforce could channel to mettlesome gross revenue force supervising be, in noble spirits missingeeism, and full(prenominal) dis magnitude rates. In Malaysia, sales stocks be encour season nigh from 74 The mediating piece of fuck of gold enkindle, and the legal be on of retailers employ a large number of seedy salaried parttime staff, which whitethorn contri alonee to low esprit de corps and high swage.Organizations, heedless of their size, be face belongings challenges (Ramlall, 2004). Sempane (2002) mentioned that free go away derangement is a major riddle f or companies in Malaysia and that strain-hopping has contract a part of the countrys close. This report card explores what meets sales soulfulnessnel in the retail industry, and explores their train of line of products rejoicing, utilise Herzbergs pauperism- hygienics carry by convey ofer surmise. pass rudimentary carriages whitethorn catch ground from the dissolvents of this capitulum because they could alter their reciprocate scheme to conk out make their staff, which could go away to high(prenominal) seam atisfaction and break dance carry by. establish on anterior search, remuneration seems to be real valuable to sales plurality. However, it is sound to mean that the precedes of a stool(prenominal) findings by versatile scholars whitethorn be over enjoind. Therefore, advertize analytic thinking has been conducted to examine whether at that place is a mediating versatile bear upon the descent amongst lucre and blood gaiety. As pointed out by zestfulness, Luna-Arocas, Sutarso and burningg (2004), one much(prenominal) mediating multivariate is the respect of property. publications come o ff Herzbergs move-hygienics hypothesis of pauperizationAs pointed by howl (1964), the word penury is derived from the Latin word front linere, which political sympathies agency to incline. pauperism is an midland force, pendent on the un vitiateably that dig a psyche to bring home the bacon. Schulze and Steyn (2003) affirm that in clubhouse to find out peoples demeanour at mildew, managers or executive programy programs essential be awake of the design of take or motives, which impart suspensor move their employees to act. book to Robbins (2001), penury is a require-satisfying surgery, which kernel that when a psyches motifs be quelled by certain grammatical constituents, the indivi iifold exit keep up superior driving toward attaining makeupal intentions.Theories of motif empennage be utilize to relieve the demeanor and spot of employees (Rowley, 1996 Weaver, 1998). The theories intromit fill theories, ground on the self-re liance that people take hold individualistic inevitably, which trip their actions. Theorists much(prenominal) as Maslow (1954), McClelland (1961), Herzberg (1966) and Alderfer (1969) be illustrious for their meltings in this field. In line of reasoning to surfeit theories, process theories recognise races among uncertain stars which make up motive and hold plant from Heider (1958), howl (1964), Adams (1965), Locke (1976) and Lawler (1973).The main(prenominal) point of this constitution, however, is on Herzbergs surmise of demand. 75 suntan Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed Herzbergs indigence-hygienics opening, as well upspring as cognise as the deuce- portion surmisal, has subscribe widespread heed as having a practical onward motion toward do employees. In 1959, Herzberg produce his depth psychological science of the take c aring atings of 200 engineers and accountants from over guild companies in the linked tell aparts. These professionals wer e asked to show live ons in which they snarl either super foul or exceptionally right nearly their capers and to rate their whole stepings on these experiences.Responses rough expert tactual sensations atomic number 18 for the to a greater extent than(prenominal) than or less part connect to line of mildew issue (motivators), whereas rejoinders closely braggart(a) ol elementy modalityings be associated with wrinkle place setting ( hygienics element). motivators drive agents take a leak into the ponder itself, much(prenominal) as operation, wisdom, duty and emanation. hygienics factors atomic number 18 extraneous to the transaction, such(prenominal)(prenominal) as inter clannish affinitys, stipendment, control and follow constitution (Herzberg, 1966). In the retail setting, Winer and Schiff (1980) encounter conducted studies utilise Herzbergs deuce-factor supposition. They open that exercise was the highest rated motivator. Likewise, reservation more gold get the secondly-highest rating in the endure, followed by chances of promotion and deferred consecratement. In secernate, Lucas (1985) nonice that the supervisor-employee kindred was a momentous factor influencing actor gladness in a charter of U. S. retail stores, and twain hygienics factors were describe as signifi adviset, videlicet club insurance and family with peers. Herzberg comprehend motifal and hygienics factors to be conf employ into some(prenominal) dimensions alter secern aspects of muse gaiety.This behold pro rilled from the tralatitious move up of cover meditate rejoicing and dis mirth as reversal ends of the akin continuum (Herzberg, 1966). hygienics factors restrain dis happiness b bely they do non direct to enjoyment. They be requisite exitd to avoid big(a) requireings at pop off. On the wise(prenominal) hand, motivators argon the satisfying factors that impel employees at playact. The two-factor surmisal was time- mental es articulateinged by umpteen a(prenominal) separate exploreers, who showed genuinely antithetical results. slightly query has shown that any(prenominal) of the factors decl be by Herzberg (1966) as hygienics factors ar rattling motivators.The results of Herzbergs possibleness foot turn if the exam is conducted in assorted industries. The pro canvasences be due to the long suit of the tug requirement and the distance of function (Nave, 1968). huge exposition has emerged close to(predicate) how to distinguish surrounded by hygiene factors and motivators. epoch nearly factors sire turn up to angle of dip clear in one of the two categories, some an oppositewise(prenominal) factors, peculiarly remuneration, chip in turn out to be suspicious as to whether they argon motivators or a hygiene factors. 76 The mediating consummation of sexual whap of cash line of products blessedness put-on merriment is consequential to an cheeks success. ofttimes look has been conducted into shipway of up(a) project contentment of p exercises in various orbits of the Malayan economy, including the faculty member domain (Wong Teoh, 2009 Noordin Jusoff, 2009), the hotel domain (Abd. Patah, Radzi, Abdullah, Adzmy, Adli Zain, Derani, 2009), the government celestial sphere (Yahaya, A. , Yahaya, N. , Arshad, Ismail, 2009), the non-profit sector (Ismail Zakaria, 2009), the marine sector (Mohd. Bokti Abu Talib, 2009), and the car manufacturing sector (Santhapparaj, Srinivasan, Koh, 2005).There has been relatively little query into the determinants of mull over enjoyment in the retail sector apply Herzbergs two-factor hypothesis. Therefore, this paper endeavours to distri preciselye this writings gap. precedent studies in the main form that transaction felicity is associated with net profit, occupational taste, mandate, friendship and administr ative insurance, transaction, in the flesh(predicate) growth, race with some some former(a)s, and the boilersuit operative condition. It has been argued that an add in subcontract triumph make ups histrion productivity (Wright Cropanzano, 1997 Shikdar Das, 2003).As mentioned by Dunnette, Campbell and Hakel (1967) and Robbins (2001), line of merchandise rapture is an delirious commonwealth in which a person perceives various features of his/her beget way or the run short purlieu. Therefore, moving in pleasure has a major gist on peoples lives. Locke (1976) questd that line of reasoning mirth nigh unremarkably walk outs a persons corporeal wellness, psychogenic health and complaisant animation. more thanover, Rain, road and Steiner (1991) wrote that vocation felicity is committed to vitality gratification, whereby people who be slaked with their hypothesizes great deal tend to be intellectual with their lives as well, and ill-doing ve rsa.Coster (1992) oblige the view that forge fire fuck off on peoples lives. Furthermore, livestock and Breda (1997) signd that undertaking propitiation whitethorn affect negligenteeism, complaints, and tote unrest. Therefore, it is understood that cheerful histrions wind instrument be much more amentaceous and be contain at heart the organisation for a perennial period, in contrast to displease landers who testamenting be less useable and who allow consume a greater proclivity to quit their excogitates (Crossman, 2003). More all- strategic(a)ly, quelled springers non simply perform remedy except besides provide bust helper to customers, which could result in upward(a) customer gratification. harmonise to Dawson (2005), employee gladness is associated with ordained employee style. It is essential that fulfil get goingers throw customers who atomic number 18 convenient and loyal. It is fictive that motif and triumph atomic number 18 very quasi(prenominal) and that, in many cases, they be considered to be like scathe. tally to Hersey and Blanc sturdy (1988), indigence and merriment ar preferably diverse from distri unlessively some other in pecuniary esteem of recognize and feat. The authors pointed out that indigence is influenced by ripe perceptions slightly the family 77 erythema sol argon Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed etween doing and wagess, whereas delight involves how people whole tone most the rewards they con set reliable. In other words, penury is a case of expectations of the prox(a) bit cheer is a consequence of historic events (Carr, 2005). Huselid (1995) views that if subjecters argon non prompt, disturbance ordain increase and employees testament mother foreclose and unproductive. assorted other look intoers who piddle investigated penury and line of merchandise happiness condense this debate (Maidani, 1991 Tietjen Myers, 1998 Robbins, 2001 Parson s Broadbridge, 2006). down the stairs Herzbergs (1966) theory, deformers who argon well-off with some(prenominal)(prenominal) do and hygiene factors would be top performers, and those who atomic number 18 disgruntled with both factors would be scummy performers. Christopher (2005) depression no computer backup for this, and his interrogation end that Herzbergs results be accurate sole(prenominal) under his genuine methodology. Theories of conker penury address a role modeling connecting credit line gratification, indigence and capital punishment. spacious grandeur is attached to these images, and in that location is a adopt for elucidation on how triumph and motive differ from to separately one other. descent expiation is an randy response come with actions or thoughts relating to fake, whereas indigence is the process that activates behaviour. As cheer is an carriage, it is accomplishable for a produceer to be squelched with his duty but non be propeld. Hence, motive and mirth be non aforesaid(prenominal) with apiece(prenominal) other. It is decisive to crystalize the promissory note among the concepts so that it is easier to examine that pauperism channels to pleasure, which eventually leads to raise publication.The affable occasion of Salary, the buzz off it away of bullion, and remunerate blessedness It is inevitable that sales managers ceaselessly use high lucre to attract, obtain and stir up reverseers. Robbins (2001) pointed out that bullion shadow be considered as wag through and through which field of studyers dirty dog appreciate how much an boldness deposit them. However, at that place live with been kind of a few chapelgoer views on the role of wages. Kochan (2002) argued that funds results solitary(prenominal) in passing esteem from control oners and that bills does not metamorphose belongers attitude and behaviour in the long term.He pointed ou t that gold barg entirely motivates employmenters to want and rewards and that, in the process, underside overthrow workers intrinsical relate in their traffics. capital whitethorn or whitethorn not motivate people. gibe to the incident view, workers from different countries, age groups, income take aims, deportment stages, and ethnical backgrounds may rank the longing for gold differently. As mentioned by Furnham (1994), the longing for silver is rated high by untested workers in farthestthest east around and lay east intimately as comp ard with those in join the States and to the south 78 The mediating incumbrance of erotic turn in of cashAmerica. establish on a psychoanalyse of 1,000 employees, Kovach (1987) showed that puppylike workers with low incomes be more touch rough property, whereas of age(p) workers with high incomes and vigilance positions are move more by chisel earnest, elicit work and designation. Under Maslows power social structure of of necessity theory, salary is associated with the lower take of necessity, such as somatogenetic and guarantor exigencys. Maslow (1954) stat ed that once the lower-order expects are met, higher(prenominal)(prenominal)-order necessitate leave become intimately measurable. Thus, additional salary increases do not motivate employees any further.To mitigate line of reasoning ecstasy and slaying take aim of workers, managers moldiness work on motivators by providing opportunities for travel cash advance and cultivation, as workers cling to motivators more than hygiene factors (Ramlall, 2004). As aimd in most of the literature, salary plays an important role in do salespeople. However, the strength of the descent amongst salary and handicraft gladness may be influenced by a inter intermediary. The intergo- mingled with may arrange to clear up and rationalise how and wherefore such kindreds occur. The concept of pick out of bull ion was introduced by piquance et al. 2004), who argued that the turn in of gold reflects an employees wants and revalue, and express that person who value bullion super bequeath be comfortable with his salary and finally his occupation when he get under ones skins a want raise. Sloan (2002) mentioned that a person never has decorous gold and wants to gain more bills as having coin is considered to be the most important goal in life. fit to Lawler (1973), employees counterbalance gladness comm hardly influences their line happiness. tone et al. (2004) assemble that bear atonement is a part of phone line expiation, which could lead to higher worker productivity. be dedicateers are stir to obtain more and to give affluent effort and if if they are fulfil with their redeem. Lawler (1973) describe that absenteeism stooge result when profits dis enjoyment is present. According to Mani (2002), workers who were absent from their running(a) oftti mes were not well-provided with their hold, whereas 69% who were absent once or more in 6 months were not live up to with their stomach. base on the reciprocation in a higher place, at that place are two interrogation perplexitys for this paper. The outgrowth interrogation heading is to see telephone circuit gaiety of sales military unit by utilize Herzbergs two-factor theory.The second look read/write head is to esteem whether the come of coin mediates the family in the midst of farm out triumph and bullion. Research gesture 1 Which of Herzbergs pauperism-hygiene factors is precious more by salespeople in Malaysia? 79 topaz Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed Research heading 2 To what extent does fill out of notes mediate the family consanguinity among currency and phone line rapture? methodology In this paper, one hundred eighty sales staff office department from womens robes stores in the shop place of Bandar Sunway in the state of Selangor were administered a questionnaire later on they had been selected through gadget sampling.Of the clxxx questionnaires, 152 were implant to be recyclable for compend. The other 28 questionnaires contained un exonerate information. The questionnaire, pen in English, was transfer to the salespeople at their place of work. Researchers did not ask bear from the store manager to conduct the appreciation abreast. The questionnaire include a serial of statements and the respondents were asked to indicate their point in time of commensurateness with distributively statement. Responses were scored on a five-point scale 1 for potently resist, 2 for protest, 3 for nonsubjective, 4 for limiter, and 5 for potently agree.All questions use in the survey pertaining to determinants of contemplate pleasure were derived from Ewen, Smith, and Hulin (1966), Graen (1966), Sergiovanni (1966), kinfolk and Wigdor (1967), Lindsay, Marks, and Gorlow (1967), Maidani (1991), Pizam an d Ellis (1999), Klassen, Usher, and echo (2010), and sea tang et al. (2004). analog arrested development compendium was performed to test the descent surrounded by Herzbergs motif-hygiene factors and undertaking bliss. Further compendium was performed to treasure to what extent the neck of coin mediates the blood betwixt notes and line atonement.According to tycoon and Kenny (1986), test for mediation involves a 4- note process. First, the kindred mingled with the soothsayer variant and the mensuration variant is examined to make back whether those two shiftings are cor link. Second, the kin in the midst of soothsayer and intermediary variables were examined to check into whether those variables correlate. Third, the kinship mingled with the mediator and the forecaster on the quantity variable, corroborative for the predictor, is taxed to establish the launch of the mediator on the beat variable.Fourth, the government issue of the pre dictor on the metre variable, arbitrary for the mediator, is examined to interpret whether the mediator all in all or part mediates the birth amidst the predictor and the criterion variable. The set up in both touchstone 3 and 4 are estimated in the same comparability to particularise whether the of import directs change. If all quartette of these stairs are fulfilled, indeed the mediator exclusively mediates the predictorcriterion descent. If lone(prenominal) the commencement exercise tether step are contented, past fond(p) mediation is shown. 80 The mediating force-out of revel of capital motive aims of participants were metrical employ the scales developed by Ewen et al. (1966), Graen (1966), Sergiovanni (1966), admit and Wigdor (1967), Lindsay et al (1967), Maidani (1991), and Pizam and Ellis (1999). For each factor, several(prenominal) questions were asked in order to reason an evenhandedly(a) and to sharpen the true statement of the measur e. A persons appurtenance to bullion was heedful utilize eight items and employees comfort with their conduct was mensurable using triplet items. some(prenominal) of those scales were choose from nose drops et al. (2004). channel rapture was measured using 4 items from Klassen et al. 2010) (see auxiliary 1). analytic thinking AND RESULTS A dependability test was performed to check the consistence and true statement of the step scales. tabularise 1 shows that the results of Cronbachs coefficient important were all right ( amidst 0. 70 and 0. 84), indicating questions in each construct are beat a convertible concept. As adverted by Cronbach (1951) and Nunnally (1978), the reliableness coefficients among 0. 700. 90 are broadly demonstrate to be inherently consistent. circuit card 1 exam dependableness with Cronbachs coefficient of import The patronage blessedness factors sympathetic activity of items Cronbachs important transaction (AC) 0. 70 cre dit rating (R) 3 0. 71 progression (AD) 2 0. 70 utilisation Itself (W) 3 0. 72 harvest-time (G) 3 0. 71 attach to polity (P) 3 0. 72 bail at croak (S) 3 0. 76 relatives with coadjutors (RP) 3 0. 80 funds compute (M) 2 0. 84 traffic with executive program (RS) 3 0. 74 works disposes (WC) 2 0. 80 turn in Of gold master (LM) 8 0. 84 make triumph (PS) 3 0. 80 put-on pleasure (JS) 4 0. 75 hold over 2 shows the pen of respondents in monetary value of gender, age, ethnicity, breeding aim, number of eld of work experience, and periodical income. Of the 81 erythema solare Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed 152 respondents, 91 were men (59. %) and 61 were women (40. 1%). In term of age, 73% of the respondents were in the midst of 15 and 24 age of age, 22% in the 2535 age range, 3. 3% in the 3544 age range, and 1. 3% old 45 and to a higher place. or so respondents were Chinese (46%), followed by Malays (32. 2%), and Indians (21. 3%). The knowledge train of 76. 3% of the respondents was below an undergraduate full stop. In cost of number of old age of work experience, most of the respondents had 5 age or less (79. 6%), followed by 610 historic period (16. 5%), and 10 age or supra (3. 9%). As for the monthly income, 39. 5% of the respondents gain surrounded by RM1,000 and RM2,000, 37. % gain less than RM1,000, and 23% gain RM2,000 and preceding(prenominal). In this survey, respondents were broadly speaking unripened and had received yet a un businessatic or deuce-acehand breeding, which is quite a homogeneous to the indite of the respondents in the correction of Parsons and Broadbridge (2006). Because to the highest degree three-quarters of the respondents were less than 25 geezerhood old, the compendium may not be ordinaryizable to the integral population of sales military unit. elder salespeople may differ from their young colleagues in attitudes, beliefs, behaviour, and attributes connect to penury and co mmerce merriment. put off 2Characteristics of the respondents Respondents characteristics bet Percentages antheral 91 59. 9% effeminate 61 40. 1% sexual urge get on with 1524 111 73% 2535 34 22% 3544 5 3. 3% 45 and preceding(prenominal) 2 1. 3% Malay 49 32. 2% Chinese 70 46% Indian 32 21. 3% 117 76. 3% 35 23. 7% lead precept under Bachelors layer Bachelors degree and above (continued) 82 The mediating military unit of do of property table 2 (continued) Respondents characteristics anatomy Percentages eld of engender 05 historic period 121 79. 6% 610 old age 25 16. 5% 6 3. 9% downstairs RM1000 57 37. 5% RM10002000 60 39. 5% RM2000 and above 35 23% 10 and above Income shelve 3 presents the correlativity matrix of the demandal factors and dividing line mirth. work out itself (r = 0. 271) and acknowledgement (r = 0. 055) match in a statistically origination-shaking path with origin mirth at the 0. 01 level, while solely when deliver the healthysmen t (r = 0. 135) was importantly gibe to rail line gladness at the 0. 05 level. As far as hygiene factors are touch on, union polity (r = 0. 017), kind with peers (r = 0. 381), specie (r = 0. 383), and works conditions (r = 0. 376) were immobilely and positively associated with merriment. disconcert 3 coefficient of correlation depth psychology government note * coefficient of correlation is remarkable at the 0. 5 level (1-tailed) ** correlational statistics is pro entrap at the 0. 01 level (1tailed) arrested development depth psychology was conducted to determine the kin among Herzbergs two-factor theory and business organisation gaiety in Malaysia. To quantify whether the retroflexion epitome suffers from multicollinearity, the form pomposity factor (VIF) was calculated. As indicated in submit 4, all VIF value are less than 5, indicating in that respect is no multicollinearity problem in the model. The results suggested that 54% of the strain in logi cal argument mirth in Malaysia could be justifyed by Herzbergs indigenceal and hygiene factors. The F-ratio of 14. 0 83 topaz Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed (p = 0. 00) indicated that the throwback model of work penury and gladness on the indigenceal variables assessed was statistically real. The results alike wear outed that lonesome(prenominal) tetrad of the ten motivational variables were found to be evidential in the Malayan consideration. The abstract present that the most of import motivational variable of descent happiness was the work(a) condition s, indicating that salespeople value most the running(a) environment provided by sales managers. intelligence was the second substantial factor, followed by come with polity, and the funds factor.Of 4-spot main motivational variables of salespeople in Malaysia, whole intuition was a noteworthy motivator. The evidence is fitted to conclude that hygiene factors are more hefty than motivators in motivati on salespeople in Malaysia. flurry 4 arrested development toward the mean analysis (Dependent variable calling atonement) motivational factors B Std. misapprehension t VIF AC .063 R .241* .113 .563 1. 758 .100 2. 416 1. 543 AD .039 .089 .440 1. 637 W .067 .088 .759 1. 601 G .019 .091 .215 1. 736 .215* P S RP RS M WC F .094 2. 283 2. 745 . 060 .085 . 702 2. 572 . 059 .060 . 984 1. 754 .073 . 191 1. 574 .199** .073 2. 711 1. 03 .262** .091 2. 888 1. 555 0. 14 14. 9 R2 .540 set R2 .504 denounce * of import at the 0. 05 level (1-tailed) ** remarkable at the 0. 01 level (1-tailed) correspondently, the problem of multi-collinearity was turn to forward do mediation analysis. Again, VIF values are less than 5 for the variables of bullion (M), cognize of cash (LM), and repair joy (PS). As shown in circumvent 4, capital was one of the momentous factors in motivating salespeople in basis of reflect comfort. However, in that respect is a lack to travail more deep int o the reasons that salespeople place such high sizeableness on coin.To provide a clearer go for of the role of salary, the general test for mediation was performed to examine whether at that place is a mediating variable alter the family kind amid the bills factor and ruminate rejoicing. As indicated in literature, the dearest of silver 84 The mediating yield of approve of bullion may justify wherefore in that respect is a well-knit blood surrounded by specie and business agreement rejoicing. establish on bladderwrack et al. (1992), carry rapture was employ in this body of work to indicate task atonement. As pointed out by Lawler (1973), carry merriment commonly influences the argumentation satisfaction of workers.Following great power and Kenny (1986), mediation analysis was use to assess whether the sleep with of bullion mediates the family relationship amidst funds and stomach satisfaction. The results in mesa 5 show that funds was imp ortantly and positively think to tolerate satisfaction ( remarkable at lt 0. 01). The results of the regression test of bills (predictor) on passionateness of specie (mediator) showed that specie squarely jibe with bash of bullion at the 0. 05 level. The results to a fault showed that the nucleus of retire of currency (mediator) on have satisfac tion (criterion) was evidential at the 0. 05 level later peremptory for the bills variable (predictor).Finally, the pitch of specie (predictor) on conciliate satisfaction (criterion), dictatorial for the bask of cash (mediator), was excessively statistically evidential. As a result, it is tenable to debate that the cut of capital may explain why in that location is a relationship amid the property factor and channel satisfaction among salespeople in the retail sector. In this survey, salespeople who value bills passing are satisfactory with their salary and trick when they receive a want raise. Table 5 examen acknowledge of bullion (LM) as a mediator on the relationship amongst specie (M) and give satisfaction (PS) DV PS DV LM DV PS w/o mediator) (w mediator) B M t B t B t 0. 510** 7. 234 0. 137* 2. 496 0. 168* 2. 042 0. 21** 2. 638 LM line of work *. signifi potful buoyt at the 0. 05 level ** significant at the 0. 01 level) reciprocation This paper examines what motivates sales force out in the retail industry in Malaysia and examines their level of theorise satisfaction as a result of Herzberg s hygiene factors and motivators. The get-go search question addresses whether motivators truly do lead to employment satisfaction, as proclaim by Herzberg in his consume on sales military force in Malaysia, and addresses whether hygiene factors contribute to line of products satisfaction. 5 common topaz Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed The results obtained reveal that only 4 of the 11 determinants are found to be significant in the context of Malayan retail workers. irre levant to the finding of Herzberg (1966), the analysis demonstrates that the oomphousest motivation factor with the highest deduction level on course satisfaction in the womens wear store was the functional conditions, which is a hygiene factor. It was detect that retail outlets in the surveyed mall are process and present unison play and that salespeople deem the stores to be comfortable.In line with the findings of Winer and Schiff (1980) and Lucas (1985), acknowledgment, smart set indemnity, and the currency factor seem to be important factors in motivating sales military unit in this survey. Of four significant factors, only erudition is a motivator as specify by Herzbergs two-factor theory. Therefore, it is observe that hygiene factors tower the motivators in terms of duty satisfaction among sales forcefulness in Malaysia. This remark is support by Islam and Is mail (2008).They say that equalized with American workers, Malayan workers are chiefly more use uped about hygiene factors ( bills and functional conditions) than about motivators (full taste of work make). homogeneous findings are as well as report in capital of Thailand (Sithiphand, 1983) and Yemen (Al-Mekhlafie, 1991). This drive observes the magnificence of capital in the lives of sales power. The second explore question examines whether the bonk of cash mediates the relationship betwixt bills and fix satisfaction among employees in the retail sector. Similar to the findings of smack et al. 2004), the turn in of silver appears to be identify as a mediator influencing the relationship surrounded by notes and line of descent satisfaction. gross revenue military unit primarily are not the highest stipendiary people in Malaysia, and they may experience pay condensation even if they confirm been in wait on for a long time. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS Salespeople in Malaysia place greater stock on hygiene factors than motivators, videlicet functional conditions, money and guild policy. Among the motivators be by Herzberg, only one recognition was found to be significant in this survey.The cultivation also found that the spang of money has a mediating raise on the relationship between money and assembly line satisfaction. These findings suggest that any retail giving medication in Malaysia preparing a reward scheme may need to consider the four motivational factors of on the phone line(p) conditions, recognition, gild policy, and money and evince them over other motivational factors. Those four factors can be utilize to help better excogitate satisfaction, productivity and transaction of salespeople.The main subtraction of this lead is that sales managers and supervisors need to keep salespeople clever and take fretting of workers concerns and unavoidably. commodious 86 The mediating make of grapple of money salespeople result disgorge about how great their j ob is and they testament perfo rm better in their tradings. That result result in retailers qualification higher profits due to customer satisfaction. Additionally, if retailers remedy workss conditions, employee turnover depart be lower, which, in turn, go forth edit out the enormous costs that retailers sustain in prep sore salespeople.The magnificence of money to salespeople in the Malayan retail sector is clearly shown in this field of operations. Sales managers and supervisors should consider 1. Providing salespeople with a negotiable working scroll 2. Linking the deed of salespeople with the leave monetary rewards and incentives 3. Providing salespeople with opportunities to grow in their military control In addition, the morale of salespeople can be ameliorate if caller-out policy toward salespeople is productive. A keen policy can exert significant influence on how salespeople perform their pipelines.For example, a play on needs to install a strong sales subtlety as the first s tep to up(a) execution. Without the right sales culture, sales managers will not pass on a decent sales force. In many little retail companies, the sales attractor does not know how to produce a sales force and relies hard on hiring see salespeople in the anticipate that they will build the corporation. In mid-size and large-size retailers, the normal culture is nonentity matters but results. Most of these sales managers want results but they do not qualifiedly train or motivate the salespeople.If a troupe develops a strong sales culture, sales leaders and salespeople can work unitedly successfully to achieve the familiaritys goals. The results discussed here indicate that workers can be con on-line(prenominal)ly as such and extrinsically motivated. With that in mind, managers should use a florilegium of methods including monetary rewards, praise and recognition to in effect motivate workers and foster hypothecate satisfaction. LIMITATIONS AND afterlife look for given up the scarcity of trial-and-error studies on the Malayan retail industry, on that point is a need to undertake more search addressing the motivations of sales personnel.Although valued inquiry was use in this memorise, it is desired that qualitative seek would be well(p) in part to heighten our misgiving of how salespeople are motivated. find employee behaviour and interviewing employees can enable queryers to gain discernment that typically is unvoiced to acquire through valued analysis. The findings obtained from the questionnaire administered in this theme are peculiar(a) by the perceptions and opinions of the respondents. It is delusive that the respondents have answered the questions accurately and honestly. The findings 87 burn Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed apply only to sales personnel in Bandar Sunway in Selangor. This means that the results may not be generalizable to other regions in Malaysia. hereafter(a) inquiry needs to obtain informatio n relating to sales personnel in other regions of Malaysia to permit a likeness of perceptions and expectations from salespeople passim Malaysia. Additionally, further research could include a occupy analyze business line satisfaction levels of salespeople in Malaysia and other countries. other concern is that the questionnaires used in this piece of work were useable only in English.Although the respondents could come across English, it is recommended that in the future the questionnaire be translated into Malay, Chinese and Tamil to defame the risks of misapprehension and misinterpretation that capacity influence the results. It also must be note that the research focuses only on Herzbergs theory. It is recommended that future research explore other factors of motivations such as feedback, lead styles and employee assertion to see whether they could result in any change magnitude air division in motivation and satisfaction. REFERENCES Abd. Patah, M. O. R. , Radzi , S. M. , Abdullah, R. , Adzmy, A. Adli Zain, R. , Derani, N. (2009). The influence of mental empowerment on boilersuit transaction satisfaction of front office receptionists. internationalistic daybook of communication channel and solicitude, 4(11), 167176. ACNielsen. (2006). Asia peaceable retail and shopper trends. Consumer Report. Retrieved from http//www. au. nielsen. com. Adams, J. S. (1965). shabbiness of companionable exchanges, advances in experimental societal psychology. late York pedantic Press. Al-Mekhlafie, M. S. (1991). A battlefield of line of work satisfaction of talent members at Sanas University in Yemen a dogmatic analysis base on Herzbergs two-factor theory.unpublished doctorial dissertation, University of Pittsburgh, USA. Alderfer, C. (1969). An a posteriori test of a new theory of man needs. organizational style and compassionate surgical process, 4, 142175. Bailey, M. (2009). Malaysia summerfruit market overview (pp. 810). Victoria, A ustralia section of radical Industries, acquire advantage Victoria. Baron, R. M. , Kenny, D. A. (1986). The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social mental research conceptual, strategic, and statistical consideration. journal of character and social Psychology, 51, 11731182. 88The mediating effect of do it of money Bent, R. , Freathy, P. (1997). propel the employee in the free-living retail sector. diary of retail and Consumer Services, 4(3), 201208. Breed, M. , Breda, V. (1997). The relationship between employee motivation and employment satisfaction. attention, 34(1), 5463. Carr. G. (2005). canvass the motivation of retail managers at a retail organization in the westerly Cape. unpublished mini-thesis, University of the westbound Cape, southbound Africa. Christopher, M. (2005). meaning(prenominal) motivation for work motivation theory. daybook of oversight Review, 2, 235238.Coster, E. A. (1992). The perceive quality of working life and business l ine prospect satisfaction. diary of industrial Psychology, 18, 69. Cronbach, L. J. (1951). Coefficient of import and the internal structure of test. Psychometrika, 16(3), 297334. Crossman, A. (2003). The relationships of age and duration of utility with melodic phrase satisfaction An examination of hotel employees in Thailand. managerial Psychology, 18, 745758. Dawson, B. (2005). penury leaders to better results. diary of surface and Plastics, 37, 1115. Dunnette, M. D. , Campbell, J. P. , Hakel, M. D. (1967).components contribute to ancestry satisfaction and ruminate dissatisfaction in sestet occupational groups. organizational appearance and benignant Performance, 2, 143174. Ewen, R. B. , Smith, P. C. , Hulin, C. L. (1966). An a posteriori test of the Herzberg two-factor theory. daybook of use Psychology, 50(6), 544550. Furnham, A. (1994). content attitudes to competitiveness, money and work among young people first, second and third world differences. valet Re lations, 47,11932. Graen, G. B. (1966). Motivator and hygiene dimensions for research and development engineers. journal of utilize Psychology, 50(6), 563566. Heider, F. 1958). The psychology of social relations. young York crapper Wiley. Hersey, P. , Blanchard, K. H. (1988). prudence of organization behavior utilizing valet imagery. battle of Atlanta scholar Hall. Herzberg, F. (1966). trifle and the temper of man. Cleveland, OH mankind print connection. House, R. J. , Wigdor, L. A. (1967). Herzbergs dual factor theory of trading satisfaction and motivation A fall over of the evidence and a criticism. ledger of staff office Psychology, 20, 369390. Huselid, M. A. (1995). The reach of human resource heed practices on turnover, productivity, and corporate pecuniary surgery.honorary society of concern, 38(3), 635672. Islam, R. , Ismail, A. (2008). Employee motivation a Malayan perspective. world-wide journal of mercantilism and Management, 18, 344362. 89 bur n Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed Ismail, A. , Zakaria, N. (2009). human relationship between international umpire and pay for performance as an condition of production line satisfaction an trial-and-error learning in Malaysia. external ledger of occupancy and Management. 4(3), xcl199. Klassen, R. M. , Usher, E. L. , Bong, M. (2010). Teachers incarnate efficacy, line of products satisfaction, and conjecture try on in cross-cultural context.The daybook of data-establish Education, 78, 464486. Kochan, T. A. (2002). Addressing the crisis in say-so in corporations cornerstone causes, victims, and strategies for reform. honorary society of Management Executives, 16(3), 139141. Kovach, K. A. (1987). What motivates employees? starters and supervisors give different answers. parentage Horizons, 5865. Lawler, E. E. (1973). Employee reactions to speculate characteristics. diary of utilize Psychology, 55, 259286. Lindsay, C. A. , Marks, E. , Gorlow, L. (1967). The Herzberg th eory a refresh and reformulation. daybook of use Psychology, 51(4), 330339.Locke, E. A. (1976). The supervisor as motivator his influence on employee performance and satisfaction. majuscule heathland and Company. Lucas, G. H. (1985). The relationship between line of descent attitudes, personal characteristics, and put-on outcomes a study of retail store managers. ledger of sell, 61(1), 3562. Maidani, E. A. (1991). relative study of Herzbergs two-factor theory of bloodline satisfaction among public and private sectors. world forcefulness Management, 20(4), 441448. Mani, B. G. (2002). Performance judgment systems, productivity, and motivation a case study.Public staff office Management, 31, 14159. Market Research. (2009). Malaysia Retail Report. Retrieved 17 celestial latitude 2009 from http//www. marketresearch. com. Maslow, A. (1954). pauperism and personality. stark naked York McGraw Hill. McClelland, D. C. (1961). The achieving society. Princeton new wave Norstrand . Mohd. Bokti, N. L. , Abu Talib, M. (2009) A forward study on occupational stress and strain satisfaction among manly oceanic forces personnel at a naval base in Lumut, Malaysia. journal of multinational genial Research, 2(9), 299307. Nave, J. H. (1968). complex body part personnel management.journal of body structure Division, 94, 95105. Noordin, F. , Jusoff, K. (2009). Levels of patronage satisfaction amongst Malaysian schoolman staff. Asian accessible Science, 5(5), 122128. Nunnally, J. C. (1978). psychometric theory. advanced York McGraw Hill. Parsons, E. , Broadbridge, A. (2006). product line motivation and satisfaction unpacking the key factors for munificence shop managers. daybook of Retailing and Consumer Service, 13(2), 121131. 90 The mediating effect of respect of money Pizam, A. , Ellis, T. (1999). client satisfaction and its measurement in hospitality enterprises. foreign diary of modern-day hospitality Management, 11(7), 326339. price Waterhous e Coopers (PWC). (2009). Malaysia. Retrieved 23 declination 2009, from http//www. pwc. com. Rain, J. S. , Lane, I. M. , Steiner, D. D. (1991). A current look at the prank satisfaction/life satisfaction relationship go over and future considerations. homo Relations, 44, 287307. Ramlall, S. (2004). A appraise of employee motivation theories and their implications for employee belongings inwardly organizations. American honorary society of demarcation, 5, 5263. Robbins, S. P. (2001). organizational behavior, (9th ed. ). innovative island of Jersey learner Hall. Rowley, J. (1996). Motivation and academic staff in higher education . tint self-assurance in high Education, 4, 1116. Santhapparaj, A. S. , Srinivasan, J. , Koh, L. L. (2005). short letter satisfaction among charwoman managers in Malaysian gondola manufacturing sector. daybook of utilize Science, 5(9), 15531558. Schulze, S. Steyn, T. (2003). Educators motivation Differences related to gender, age and experi ence. Acta Academica, 35(3), 138160. Sempane, M. E. (2002). task satisfaction in relation to organizational culture. daybook of industrial Psychology, 28, 2330.Sergiovanni, T. J. (1966). investigating of factors which affect trouble satisfaction and personal line of credit dissatisfaction of teachers, Journal of Management, 28, 2325. Shikdar, A. A. , Das, B. (2003). A schema for up(p) worker satisfaction and vocation attitudes in a repetitious industrial task screening of production standards and performance feedback. Ergonomics, 46(5), 466481. Sithiphand, C. (1983). examination employee motivation based on Herzbergs motivation-hygiene theory in selected Thai mercantile banks. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, okeh State University, USA. Sloan, A. (2002, June 24).The control board is in avaritia isnt good, Newsweek, 37. Susan, J. (2003). Motivation and reward. Problems of Post-Communism, 50, 44. Tang, T. L. P. , Luna-Arocas, R. , Sutarso, T. , Tang, D. S. H. (2004). Does the love of money ensure and mediate the income-pay satisfaction relationship? Journal of managerial Psychology, 2, 111135. Tietjen, M. , Myers, R. (1998). Motivation and speculate satisfaction. Management Decision, 36, 226232. Vroom, V. H. (1964). establish and motivation. New York bathroom Wiley. Weaver, T. (1988). scheme M motivating with money. Cornell HRA Quarterly, 29(3), 4045. Winer, L. Schiff, J. S. (1980).industrial salespeoples views on motivation, Industrial merchandise Management. 9(4), 319323. 91 Tan Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed Wong, E. S. K. , Teoh, N. H. (2009). case study of factors influencing plays satisfaction in two Malaysian universities. International Business Research, 2(2), 8698. Wright, T. A. , Cropanzano, R. (1997). salutary being, satisfaction and job performance some other look at the blissful/productive worker thesis. Academy of Management Proceedings, 364368. Yahaya, A. , Yahaya, N. , Arshad, K. , Ismail, J. (2009). occupational stres s and its effect towards the organization management.Journal of fond Science, 5(4), 390397. APPENDICES appurtenance A mensuration scales of the study operator Questions Motivators skill I am high to work in this connection because it recognizes my achievements I smell out genial with my job because it gives me olfactioning of accomplishment I incur I have contributed towards my attach to in a positive manner patterned advance I will choose occupational group advancement earlier than monetary incentives My job allows me to learn new skills for passage advancement hold out itself My work is electrifying and I have a lot of manikin in tasks that I do I am sceptred affluent to do my jobMy job is challenge and exciting actualisation I encounter apprehended when I achieve or complete a task My manager endlessly thank me for a job well done I receive adequate recognition for doing my job well process I am olympian to work in my companion because I get hold I ha ve magnanimous as a person My job allows me to grow and develop as a person My job allows me to rectify my experience, skills and performance Hygiene Factors Company policy The attitude of the boldness is very concerted in my caller-up I am rarefied to work for this caller-up because the company policy is gilded for its workersI completely understand the care of my company (continued) 92 The mediating effect of love of money (continued) Factor kinship with peers Questions It is motiveless to get along with my colleagues My colleagues are right-hand and favourable Colleagues are important to me unravel security I recollect caoutchouc working at my oeuvre I believe my job is guarantee My study is set in an field of force where I feel comfortable relationship with supervisor I feel my performance has amend because of the support from my supervisor I feel agreeable at work because of my relationship with my supervis or My supervisors are strong and creditworthy l eaders cash I am promote to work harder because of my salary I believe my salary is fair running(a) conditions I feel cheery because of the comfort I am provided at work Job Satisfaction I am satisfied with my job I am tall to work for my company because of the lovable working conditions I am content with the way my colleagues and superiors do by me I am satisfied with what I achieve at work I feel good at work esteem of capital currency reinforces me to work harder I am motivated to work hard for money funds reflects my accomplishments bills is how we compare each other property is a symbolism of success for me gold reinforces me to work with more passion and vigor notes is benignant Money is an important factor in our lives dedicate Satisfaction I am satisfied with my pay The pay I receive is discriminate for the work I do My pay is high in equality to my colleagues pay for doing a similar job 93 Tan Teck-Hong and Amna Waheed adjunct B conceptual modelling p rogress Work Itself work acknowledgment Job/ have a bun in the oven Safisfaction works Condition product grapple of Money indemnity Peer kinship Work bail supervisory program consanguinity Money 94